• Square Elite
  1. If you are having trouble logging in, check the box, "stay logged in" to fix the issue. Thanks! —KHP Staff
  2. Hi Guest, you may have noticed that we aren't khplanet.com anymore. For more information on why these changes are happening, check out our thread, Site Re-Brand Updates

Xehanort = Unverse Theory

Discussion in 'Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep' started by Soul Knight, Aug 31, 2009.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Soul Knight

    Soul Knight Guest

    Hi everyone, this is my first unverse theory on this site. ^_^

    Well in the recent interview Nomura confirmed the unbirths were actually called the unverse. He also said unverse are those not well versed in life/existence in other words the unverse do not know anything regarding life.

    Nomura later went on to say that unverse are born and grow from negative emotions.

    Then it hit me like a rock! Young Xehanort is Terra's unverse! It was so obvious.

    Just so some wont confuse Xehanort with MX, this is the Xehanort I am talking about:

    [​IMG]




    Let's start of with Terra himself. Terra and MX have a bad relationship, that is clear. In KH2FM+ Terra in the optional battle said this:

    So Terra only has hatred toward Xehanort, huh? If that is all he has left then would'nt that make him the same as an unverse?

    If unverse know nothing except for negative emtoion and Terra only knows negative emotion then they would be the same or atleast similar, right?

    Okay so here is what I think happens. Terra's hatred for Master Xehanort is so strong that he becomes an unverse. Except Terra keeps his human form so he is a human shaped unverse. The negative emotions effect his appearance causing him to have white hair, tan skin, and brown eyes.

    Now what evidence do I have that Young Xehanort is Terra transformed into an unverse? Alot actually.

    Now remember that when Ansem the wise found young Xehanort/Terra all young Xehanort could remember is the name "Xehanort". "Xehanort" is the name of the man that cause all of Terra's hatred. So if young Xehanort is Terra's unverse then it would make sense that the only thing he remembers is the name of the man he hates, Master Xehanort.

    My next peice of evidence is the many things Xemnas said in KH2 and remember that Xemnas like all nobodies remember what it was like to have a heart:

    Xemnas to Ansem the wise:

    Notice how Xemnas said he could understand Ansem being consumed by jealousy. Jealousy is a negative emotion. Xemnas did'nt understand anyother reason as to why Ansem would try to destroy him. Again this is another example of how an unverse is like.

    The next quote is what he said to the artificial Kingdom Hearts in KH2:

    Rage, Anger, and Envy. All of these are negative emotions and Xemnas continues to go on about these emotions.

    The next quote is when Xemnas was speaking to Sora after he was beaten in the second battle with him in KH2:

    So here it is, the big peice of evidence. Nobodies remember what it was like to have a heart so they would also remember emotion. However Xemnas said that he does'nt remember anything but anger and hate. Both of these are negative emotions and they are the same negative emotions that Terra had for MX.

    I think it's pretty clear now that Young Xehanort is Terra transformed into an unverse. All Xehanort/Xemnas remembers is negative emotions and Terra said all he had left was hatred for Master Xehanort so along with physicial similarities it seems likely now that Young Xehanort is Terra transformed into an unverse and keeping his human form.

    ---------------------------------------------------------
    Well glad I got that over with.
     
  2. EtherealSummoner

    EtherealSummoner Lamentations 3:22-26

    ^_^ that's a great theory, but if Xehanort is terra's unverse, then how come Terra fought Sora in KH2 FM then? Terra shouldn't exist if his unverse is made.
     
  3. Soul Knight

    Soul Knight Guest

    Nomura confirmed a long time ago that the battle with Terra in KH2FM+ was not canon. That battle never really happened, it was just used so the fans would be able to get a look a what the future of KH was going to be like.

    Now the dialouge Terra used before and after that battle is canon, that's official. So when Terra told sora all he had was hatred toward Xehanort, that dialouge is consider to be official. But Terra and Sora never met in KH2FM+. The battle was just for fun, the dialouge is official.
     
  4. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    *yawns* was waiting for somone to post something about unverse but i was hoping no one would, but you do have som legit points.

    whats the point?

    Its the only hatred he has at the time.
    What if Xehanort did something too Aqua or Ven?
    Breaking there bond, he could hate him for no reason
    and IF he was Terra's unverse, wouldn't he be made because of Terra's hatred toward someone else and not him?
    Ontop of that why would its name be Xehanort?
    um ontop of that im pretty sure Xehanort was a human.
    An apprentice of AtW
    Ontop of that, i doubt that an Unverse can have a Heartless and Nobody
    ONTOP OF THAT. why does xehanort have, IF being an unverse have the form of a human .
    blah this is way to simple to take apart
    answer those questions and you may have a point
    the most legit thing you could have said is Xehanort is MX's apprentice..I may have no commented

    yea so why wouldn't that negative emotion make an unverse and not the unverse already been made and have a heartless and nobody?

    why does he keep this form? because of why?...


    none actually

    Um Terra doesn't look young. He looks in the 17-20..Maybe older, not so young,
    young im thinking 4
    but can't say it isn't a good point, but i think not





    Xemnas couldn't understand, he ACTED like he understood, nobodies don't have emotions..

    Nobodies don't have these there for Xemnas couldn't understand..


    Again all emotions, don't put Xemnas with emotions, becuase he can't feel these what so ever..



    wow..
    Nobodies DO NOT have emotions, they don't remember, they don't feel emotions at all
    No
    he remembered what HE THOUGHT was anger and hate, he didn't know these emotions. Xemnas wanted his heart back so he could feel emotions..therefore you have no evidence in this part

    Xemnas didn't remember negative emotiosn, because again he can't feel them

    When terra said this im pretty sure it wasn't canon unless you can show me proof it was, becuase i heard it was. and again when terra did say that, these negative emotions should have made Xehanort, and how do we know he isn't talking about MX? because Terra did call MX, just xehanort before..

    btw not that many similarites, but hairstyle and eye color, and thats eye color we only saw once from terra :p
     
  5. Soul Knight

    Soul Knight Guest

    Wow! There are so many things wrong with this.

    Look can you shorten all this so I can adress it properly because I don't have the time to go through all this and stuff.

    Everything you are saying is really confusing. I don't understand some of the things you are trying to say.

    Shorten this up and make it clear what you are saying and then I will gladly adress this.
     
  6. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    Yes i know there is so many things wrong with your theory, thats why i addressed them

    basically your wrong, i can't shorten it because there are so many errors in your theory its ridiculous
    but ill point out the MAIN things

    You say terra says something abou Xehanort right?

    Well Terra calls MX, Xehanort, he doesn't call him MX, he calls him Xehanort
    so how do you know Terra is talking about Apprentice Xehanort, Im thinking he is talking about MX
    and i can put up a stronger argument then that.

    You say Xemnas can feel emotion?

    He can't he just acts like he can. That is one of the main traits of a nobody, so whatever you said about Xemnas is basically wrong.

    Unverse part.

    I don't think Xehanort is an unverse, reasons:

    1) why does he have human form?

    2) Terra isn't young he is 17-20, im thinkin AtW found a child

    3) Im sure its impossible for an unverse to have a Nobody and Heartless

    there are many other reasons but these are the main points

    Also

    You are saying, Terra is an unverse, because he hates Xehanort?

    then you say that Xehanort is terra?

    So why would he hate himself?

    maybe your Theory is confusing..

    Also.

    If Terra were an Unverse, and he said he hated Xehanort, he seems pretty happy in some of the trailers ive seen, so he couldn't really be an unverse at that time.

    Basically your contradicting youself a little
     
    Last edited: Aug 31, 2009
  7. Answer Man

    Answer Man Man I'm Awesome

    HEY HEY HEY how would a unverse have a heartless and nobody? plus i think maybe the atw apprentice dude is just terra i mean he looks just like him right? without the colors terra has, and he remember xehanort right, maybe cause he became a unverse then or he just nearly got took-en by darkness and somehow MX was able to go inside of his heart, but it didn't work and he got trapped but not without trying to change terra into himself, casue MX has a white beard(this is the worst analogy) so maybe that's why atws apprentice has white hair and same color eyes as MX, cause MX nearly changed terra that's why he remembered his name, cause the first thing you get when your made is your name. so what about it?
     
  8. Soul Knight

    Soul Knight Guest

    I meant there was many things wrong with your first post, I could'nt understand anything you were saying.

    Okay first of all I never said that Terra mentioned anything about the young Xehanort.

    Whenever I said that Terra said something about Xehanort I assumed you knew I was talking about MX.

    Common sense would tell you that, Duh!

    I never said that Terra was saying he had hatred toward the young xehanort. I said he had hatred toward MX.

    So you were confused there.

    No I did'nt. I said he remembers what it was like to have a heart and if he remembers what it was like to have a heart then he must remember what it was like to have emotion.

    Yeah and Xemnas uses his memories of when he had a heart in order to pretend like he has emotions

    1. Because unverse may still be whole beings in the sense they still have a body, heart, and soul. So Terra being a keyblade weilder may have been strong enough to keep a human form even as an unverse.

    2. WTF? You don't think 17-20 is young? To me 17-20 is young. Ansem never said he found a child. He said he found a young man. A child is not a young man. A young man is anywhere from being a teenager to like 25 years old.

    3. Not if unverse have a body, soul, and heart. I mean who said there was any seperation of the body, soul, and heart when an unverse is made?



    I am saying that Terra hates Master Xehanort.

    This hatred causes Terra to become an unverse and when he becomes an unverse the only thing he remembers is the name "Xehanort" which is MX's name. Since MX is the man that Terra hates it would make sense that he remembered the name of the man he hates which is "Xehanort"

    Then when Terra/Young Xehanort/Terra's unverse was found by Ansem the wise the only thing Terra/Young Xehanort/Terra's unverse remembered was the name Xehanort so he assumed that was his name and Terra/Young Xehanort/Terra's unverse started to call himself "Xehanort"

    I never said that he was an unverse all through out BBS. I meant Terra becomes an unverse at the end of BBS. Remember when his eyes turned yellow in the secret trailer of KH2FM+ that showed a that battle between TAV and MX and his apprentince that was confirmed to take place near the end of BBS? That's when I think Terra becomes an unverse.

    Which means he was'nt an unverse before that.
    ----------------------------------------------------------

    You were confused and you misunderstood what I said and what I meant. I'm sorry you were confused and you did'nt have to act like a smart ass.

    Now I hope I made it clear exactly what I meant. I figured you had enough common sense to understand what I meant. If it was confusing then i'm sorry but I hope it is clear now.

    Odd though how summonerbrandon understood what I was saying and you did'nt.

    Now I hope I made it clear.
     
  9. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    Okay now i finally grasped you theory, and for the sake of argument, i read this in class so i rushed through it, ontop of that wasn't being a smart ass, you theory is okay, but has holes.

    Like why would terra turn into an unbirth wouldn't he make one?
     
    Last edited: Sep 1, 2009
  10. Desert Warrior

    Desert Warrior Well-Known Member

    Just to point out, the battle in KH2: FM+ isn't against Terra (Unless Nomura has actually said that the boss is Terra).

    1) Maybe if he's a strong enough Unverse, he could look human. After all, the strongest of Nobodies look human.

    2) 17-20 is considered the age of being a Young Adult. And in that memory scene of Mickey's, where he's talking to AtW, and Young Xehanort comes in, you said that it takes place approx. 1 year after BBS. So AtW couldn't have found Young Xehanort as a child unless AtW found Young Xehanort years before BBS. But I seriously doubt anybody here thinks that.

    3) We don't know enough about Unverses. So (since their traits are still truly unknown), it can go either way. It's still a possibility for Unverses to have Nobodies and Heartlesses, if it is a strong enough Unverse.

    That's my comment for now.
     
  11. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    1) I doubt it 2

    2)Yes i thought he said young boy, but he said young man, so that was my mistake

    3) If unverse have nobodies and heartlesses they would still exist in KH1 time, they don't.
     
  12. Desert Warrior

    Desert Warrior Well-Known Member

    1 & 3 are just guesses. Until BBS comes out/more info is revealed about the Unverse, we don't really know what's possible.

    And (For argument's sake), let's say Terra made an Unverse (Young Xehanort). And let's say he's the most powerful Unverse. Maybe, just maybe, he eliminated every other Unverse during his experiments, and ended up creating the Heartless.
     
  13. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    ha 3 isn't a guess sense its been confirmed, that Unverses/unbirth aren't in Kh1 time.

    Yes, i don't have a problem with him making an unverse, no problem there. He was just saying Terra turned into an unverse. I don't like that theory.

    But your most powerful unverse sounds no good, why would he eliminate all of his kind?
     
  14. Desert Warrior

    Desert Warrior Well-Known Member

    Mabye they died out because of his experiments with the heart. And thinking about point 3, maybe when and Unverse forms a Heartless or a Nobody, they can't return to being an Unverse. So in that case, Young Xehanort could have experimented on them, turning them into Heartless. And maybe he had some object that would draw Unverse to him, so he could have a hearty supply of test subjects.

    And, a question popped into my mind. For about a year now, the Unverse have been called Unbirth, right? And clearly, Nomura would've heard of the mistranslation months before now. So I'm forced to question why Nomura didn't correct people earlier. Do you think there's a possibility that he had a reason for letting people think they were called Unbirth this whole time?
     
  15. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    Hmm if that were true they would still be around during Sora's keyblade reign. I don't think so but possibly.

    Honestly thinkng the same, i think t was to throw us off,
     
  16. Soul Knight

    Soul Knight Guest

    You should'nt have rushed through my theory. It caused you to become confused.

    Now as I stated before it's likely that unverse do have a heart, body, and soul. Because if seperation of these three were involved in making an unverse then the remains would have created another creature in BBS like the nobodies. Since no such creature exist, then it's likely unverse are body, soul, and heart.

    If that is the case then Terra would not have created an unverse, he would have become an unverse.

    Trust me nearly everyone on KHinsider believes the same thing as I do.

    Now ofcourse my theory has some holes. Every theory has holes, that is why they are called theories. I'm not Nomura so I can't tell you exactly how everything really happens in KH.

    I'm just taking what I know and trying to work in a way that fits.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Oh yeah btw Desert Warrior, don't blame Nomura about the whole unbirth/unverse translation confusion. Since he lives in japan he could'nt have known we in America thought they were called unbirths. In japan they had been calling them unverse but it seems Nomura found out there was confusion and corrected us in the recent interview.
     
  17. x3pic

    x3pic I'll Kill You.

    Yea or maybe it was confusing because you said Xehanort instead of Master Xehanort, thats the only part that got me


    ]
    This I do agree and I can see, but your argument still isn't strong enough to prove that Terra transformed into an unverse, because really we don't know what they are, which just know basics,

    Nobodies can keep human forms if they originally had a strong heart

    Two people kept human forms as just hearts, after they were supposed to turn into heartless, because they had a strong heart

    Now with unverse, since nothing has been lost, why can Terra suddenly keep his human form as an unverse?

    Don't get me wrong, Its a good thought, because it came across my mind when I read the nomura interview.
    I thought back to the KH2 Secret Ending Trailer, when Terra gets angry and his eye color starts to change, thought he was becoming an unverse, but then i thought, well MX's eyes are the same color, what if he is an unverse, and terra is finally crossing between the wall of light and darkness, to a side that is negative, an unverse side.

    that is what you can not answer.
    If that is the case then Terra would not have created an unverse, he would have become an unverse.
    Idc about anyone on KHinsider, so this has no meaning, just because everyone believes doesn't mean i have to, its not a trend, its a theory.


    Actually thats not why they are called theories, to be exact, but not even Nomura can tell us exactly how things happen in KH

    This is understandable, but there isn't enough information to make anything fit, atleast wait until more information is released.
     
    Last edited: Sep 1, 2009
  18. Saix

    Saix New Member

    You can take Xehanort and get No Earth + X out of it.
    Terra = Earth.
    OSHT-

    Could just be coincidence though.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page