SOTW 5 [Voting]

SOTW 5
VOTING THREAD

Theme: Music
​

Voting System

Choose your top 3 preferences and give a brief explanation on why you chose it.

In order for your entry to be counted you MUST vote.

Example:
A: First Preference (Worth 3 points)
D: Second Preference (Worth 2 points)
C: Third Preference (Worth 1 point)

Entrants in posting order:
Roaringflames
FatewithFury
Zol
Kitty
H.SummonerBWM
Jade Balfour
Malibu
keybladelegacy
noz


Entries:

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I ​

Voting Closes May 11th.
YOU MUST VOTE IN ORDER FOR YOUR ENTRY TO COUNT!​

 

So hard.... I do not have a lot to comment.

1st: I. It is real colorful and I also like the swirl.

2nd: C . I like the green Rainbow but I just cannot read the text. What is her name again?

3rd: B. This gives me a 1860's feeling. Still, I feel that musical note is...out of place for some reason. I don't know why.

 

E: Why are you so amazing. Would have been better without the purple.

A: Haha David Bowie, it has an aged look to it.

H: Guitar look LQ and your lighting is in the wrong place but i love the amount of potential your works have.

 

1st. F
This piece is very nice. It's simple, clean and it the color scheme matches everything overall. I'm loving the text used too. Nice job.

2nd. A
Clean and simple as well. One thing I see that stands out the most is the nebula like effects on the sides. It would have worked better if the left side could have got more of that effect, that would also add in a more blended effect.

3rd. E
I really like the two tone color you used here. Usually, I'm not a big fan of that, unless they're both blended in as 2 alternating colors. But, you pulled it off nicely, The effects could be a bit toned down, but nonetheless, nice work.

 

F : Nice flow, colours fit perfect also depth is on point.

A : Same for this tag, it may have a lot of negative space, but overall it's cool beanz.

E : It's ace, although the text needs to blend in more. Also , adding "black" smoke brushes overtop of lady gaga with a few light sources isn't anything worth jumping up for. Be more creative next time.

 

A: Really plain and simple, Looks so basic, Yet so good, deserves first

C: Really colorful, though bad placement on the render

E: really fancy but only smoke of somewhat, good placement of different color changing

 

1. E-I like the color mixture and how everything around Lady Gaga is placed and used

2. C-I love the rainbow placement, the pic of the artist used, and the color choices

3. H-it looks like he's praying while rocking out with a great blend of colors

 

F: OMG i hate that song! but amazing sig! I like how the Backround is made up of just Text and the one line.
C: Lol love zee colors, nice render of Taylor Swift, and are those music notes?!?! they look cool, execcelent work!
E: i personaly am not a fan of lady gAGA and seeing that sig made me start laughing with joy!!!!!! nice two tone.

 

Voting extended until the 11th due to all these lovely database errors.

 

F: Not sure why, I'm really liking this one. Maybe because someone got free tickets for her show on Thursday night last week here =P (It was my friend... At least I met her DJ in person)
Anyway, liking the black and blue usuage and how they all fit so well with eachother. Almost flawless with Katy in fron as well. Almost flawless with everything. Somewhat simple but effective way to make a sig.

A- Really bringing out David Bowie for me. It actually looks like him during his live shows. He's all the glam and the environment is stone cold dark, though you've changed it to be something better by adding a bit of colour into it.

E: Besides the text and black smokey things, I'm liking this one.

Followed very closely with B, H and C

Everyone seems to have improved during my time away. Great Job to all.

 

A- You know what this one was really unique... If you noticed almost all the entries used text, some of them even as the focal. I think this sig not having text really gave it an upper hand in the uniqueness ctegory...
as for the effects, they are... well stunning. Love everything about this sig...

E- Man you have talent, I mean my only problem with this one is that choice of color, and most of it does not seem to be made by you... so other than that great brush usage, and text placement.

F- It is good, but not the best one you have done yet, It has awesome text effects... and good depth.... but for some reason i just feel like there is something missing...

 

Alright results are in and holy crap was it a close one.
1st Malibu 18points
2nd Kitty 17points
3rd Jade Balfour 16points.

Literally one vote could have changed the outcome here.
SOTW6 is up and running so FLOCK TO IT!!!
~Closed~​