Is Judging Right?

Being Judged is horrable. i would know. i get judged everyday. in fact i get bullied. I fight for unity. and when the world sees that we bleed and breath the same way. then there will be peace.

 

@angel so what your saying is... if you saw someone in all black and neon colors. looking out of society, you would judge them?

 

Point is. being judged is just pointless. its the persanality that matters.

 

In my personal opinion I believe judging is the right thing to do based on the situation, after you have more facts about someone and something and believe you have a solid understanding of the who, what, when, where, how I believe it is your right to judge based on facts and your beliefs while on the other hand when you have no idea what the heck your talking about, judging is far from righteous and loses it's meaning as judgement and becomes empty criticism with any empty mind.

 

You may all think this way. but i know how it really feels to be judged every single day.....

 

Not nessisarily. but whatever.

 

Judging is needed and not needed. Let me break it down for you...

Sterotypical Judging, Bullying, Teasing, etc.=Bad Judging=Not needed: This judging as we all try so hard to eliminate needs to be gone, however it will not. I'm going to refer to the bible, and explain this scientifically as well. Brandon your quote from the bible refers to this type of judging. "Judge notso that you will not be judged" means that people should not judge somebody so they won't be judge that way. It's like you tease somebody to make yourself look like the tough one so you do not get judge the way you're judging that particular person.

Judging in the bible, when speaking about this, is bad, it is a sin. We put others of the same kind down and we classify them terribly, it makes so many lives horrible. However as a sin is a sin it cannot be stopped. This something can be viewed as a natural occurrence, with not only our species but all species. For instance, wolves only the strongest can be the alpha, and though they fight somehow the alpha always remains the alpha, the omega is the weakest but what test does the omega go through to be proven the weakest?

I know this teacher at school, he is against bullying particularly teasing and stereotyping. He however completely unaware of this does the very thing he's against. If it be about a particular student who doesn't do his work or that one teacher who is not allowing a student to work on a project for his class or to come down and hang up posters. He stereotypes and judges others completely unaware he does this.


Criminal Judge, Law Enforcer: So just the other day we had a guest speaker in one of my classes come in and speak to my sociology class about the way the law is judged and how punishment is served now a days in court. I was surprised, but at the same time not surprised to see that there are several cases where people go straight to serving jail time and paying a large amount of money without going to court meanwhile there are cases where a court hearing needs to be held for people you know committed a crime.

For instance the state of New York was the example he used, has it where if you own an unlicensed gun, you had to go serve 5 years in jail, and pay this huge fine. You had no court hearing or a chance to fight against it. He didn't go any further about this, but I look at this and I find it ridiculous for that. Number one, what if it's a poor guy and he lives in a poor unsafe area of New York City with his wife and two kids. The family can barely support themselves and risk every night there apartment being broken into, the husband murdered, the wife and daughter raped and sons murdered. How are they going to defend themselves, by having that gun they have added safety, but they can't afford to buy food so they're not going to spend the money on a gun license. Next example a father may have just lost his young son in war. His son owns a gun that he now owns. He never going to use the gun, but it was his son's treasured gun so he's not going to get rid of it, why pay for the gun license if it's not being used and is maybe sitting on display?

I could think of several more examples, but those are just some. In the state of New York however, murder and rape and kidnapping criminals get a court hearing, and they could be guilty and known to be guilty such as video surveillance, however they get a chance to fight against the judge. How fair is it to the poor man owning an un-license gun has to go to jail without a chance to speak against it where as the murderer caught on camera shooting a man gets the chance to fight against it?

Also judges(or rather now in the U.S., jury deciding the judgement) are needed in helping to punish criminals. They may not be police officers, but they are defending the streets by giving a life sentence to the murderer.


Self-Judgement, Gut, Heart/Mind/Soul- Self judgement is very important, it allows us to judge what's good and what's bad, what's safe and what's not, what to do and what not to do. Without it the whole world would be in ruin as we harmed ourselves and others, bad and good things stop seizing and became complete chaos, and we wouldn't know how to save our world.




There are several more forms of judgement, some good some bad, it all depends. These three reading your first post is what strikes me as being the most important forms of judgement.

 

Why not break down this whole right/wrong thing, for the lulz.

First off, I'm gonna go ahead and post my conclusion first. Each of you are only human. If you wish, go ahead and judge. If you don't wish to judge, then don't. Although (Again, for the lulz) I might as well point out to all of you who are saying judging is wrong that the moment you come up with an opinion about what I am saying, each and every one of you will have judged me and my opinion.

Anyways, the question of this thread (Is judging right) is too broad to properly debate. First off, right how? The action itself? Doing it just because we can? What if you judge somebody, and good or bad you do nothing with your judgement? If we are to ask if judging is right, first there needs to be something established that explains what is meant by right. Morally, ethically, etc.

Secondly (And a swerve towards a more philosophical question), is anything right or wrong? To be honest, I'm going to lean more towards no (Also, to whomever may try to debate this point, do not bring religion into it. I am talking about humans alone and nothing else). We only deem something right or wrong because something in our lives influenced us to make such a decision. But in a scenario such as this (Again, is judging right), who is to say that either argument is right? For those of you who say judging is wrong; what makes your opinion right? And for those of you who say judging is right; same question. If you're going to take something that humans do every damn day (And trust me, you do judge every day), can you really deem it right or wrong? Judging is second nature to a person. Saying that judging is right or wrong is like saying breathing is right or wrong. It is neither and instead it is simply something we do. You can make your own decision to control these things (Judging and breathing), but once you forget to make your own decision your body will automatically do it.

So, again, you're all human. Judge if you want to, don't judge if you don't want to.

 

I agree judging is both right and wrong.
And lol destiny I love it that you go and write us a report about this lol

 

*facepalm summoner* that part of it going against the judgement he's referring to. The last one would be that judgement.

And as I said pretty much the samething as DW but gave examples of different ones, you can't stop judgement, it's part of human nature.