• Square Elite
  1. If you are having trouble logging in, check the box, "stay logged in" to fix the issue. Thanks! —KHP Staff
  2. Hi Guest, you may have noticed that we aren't khplanet.com anymore. For more information on why these changes are happening, check out our thread, Site Re-Brand Updates

SOTW 9 [Voting]

Discussion in 'Archive' started by Plasmos, Aug 10, 2011.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Plasmos

    Plasmos Plasmos

    SOTW 9 VOTING
    Sora

    Choose your top 3 preferences and give a brief explanation on why you chose it.
    In order for your entry to be counted you MUST vote.

    Example:
    A: First Preference (Worth 3 points)
    D: Second Preference (Worth 2 points)
    C: Third Preference (Worth 1 point)




    A. [​IMG]




    B. [​IMG]




    C. [​IMG]
     
  2. Tetiro

    Tetiro New Member

    Favourite - B
    Average - C
    Least - A

    I just liked B's better
     
  3. LDC1121

    LDC1121 New Member

    First Preference: B
    I love the swirling mass of lights around Sora and blue is my favorite color so I'm going to have to pick this as my fave.

    Second Preference: C
    This one is also very well done, the colors blend together nicely and Sora is incorporated into the signature perfectly. Another great job indeed.

    Third Preference: A
    I like the signature as well, but I feel like its missing something. It doesn't pop out at me like the other 2 signatures do. I don't know what exactly could be added to it to make it stand out more, but I definitely feel like it needs something.
     
  4. Plasmos

    Plasmos Plasmos

    A. Meh. Could use a lot of work, still it's beginners.

    B. Bleh. The oversaturated and blue neon is quite hideious and it looks very sloppy. You can see layers of blending NOT blending in so well with the other components. Sora is discolored, and his skin looks trifling. Just not a well put sig if you ask me.
     
  5. Angel

    Angel Lion Heart Staff Member Administrator

    C. Is the best of three, in my opinion. Although, I dislike the blue orbs and the red orb by "Oblivion". They were the first things I noticed and are way too distracting. Bottom left, there is a bubble and on that bubble is some markings that shouldn't belong.

    Sora is well blended, i enjoy the oblivion key in the background, and the topaz sparkles.

    A. Sora is not as blended as good as he could be. It's a pretty simple sig.
     
    Last edited: Aug 10, 2011
  6. VentusSearcher

    VentusSearcher Steam is the only way....

    B
    C
    A

    I don't really have like intelligent opinions so I'm just gonna keep myself from looking stupid
     
  7. Napoléon

    Napoléon Kuroko Fangirl

    I feel as though I should mention that I'm not a Graphic Designer, I probably couldn't make a sig to the caliber of any of these.

    C. What a pretty signature, I adore the colours in it and the way they mesh into each other. I also like the orbs/circles that are consistent throughout the entire sig. The lighting used complements the entirety of it too.

    A. Sora's red hot in this one ! I'm not a big fan of the font choice, it could be better, but I do like how when you look from right to left the red tones get deeper until you have a purple colour in the bottom left corner. The swirls by Sora also look neat.

    B. This one isn't bad, I don't like all of the boxes I see though. They're distracting, in my opinion, and I don't know what they're even for (They look more like rectangles really in the background.) Aside from that, the bubbles are nice and Sora reminds me as if he's submerged under water.
     
  8. Remedy

    Remedy Remnant

    C- Great, not much else to say really.

    B- The C4d's are horrible.
    I can see why people like it, but it's really messy.
    The C4d's are cut off in strange places and overlap sora way too much.
    Not blendend at all.

    anyone gonna show up and enter nowadays? sheesh
     
  9. ADogX

    ADogX R.I.P. Captain Unohana

    1. C. Looks awesome. Not simple
    2. A. Great use of the red
    3. B. Too simple
     
  10. Plasmos

    Plasmos Plasmos

    Don't worry, I'm sure they'll be more entries next time, especially with the new updates and installations to the forums. Maybe next time.
     
    Last edited: Aug 10, 2011
  11. Noir

    Noir

    B.
    Blue is my favorite color. I liked the designs and the face of Sora. It's like a dream. Awesome.

    C.
    Do just a little text. Maybe 3. I liked the designs too. It's a little great, but not bad.

    A.
    So very little blurry, but cool the background a little. Sora and the text are just okay.
     
  12. Cameron

    Cameron New Member

    C - a lovely design indeed ~ I'm loving the colors and how simple the sig is, this stands out best of the three.

    A - Nice, but feels a little empty and I'm not really loving the text. :# The bg is great an fits the scheme but somehow Sora pops out too much and the text doesn't really give points to the sig.

    B - This one is the one I most liked - I don't like it when Sora's render is in the absolute middle and there's just too many things going on. + I don't really like that Sora fades out so much to the bg. u_u
     
  13. Kitty

    Kitty I Survived The BG Massacre Staff Member Administrator

    C: The best-crafted signature; I like the render placement and the effects, but I do think the colors are a little icky. They work together and all, but they're just not what I would choose for myself, I guess.

    A: I don't like the text and the lighting kind of washes out Sora's face a little. It's okay, but could use work.

    B: Too many effects going on for my liking, without depth or blending.
     
  14. EtherealSummoner

    EtherealSummoner Lamentations 3:22-26

    1. A. I chose this for my very own reasons. It is not overworked but it does not have a lot in there. The text is ok but it is CLEAN. The text should be styled differently though.

    2. C. This is better than B but really: Sora has something blue on his left shoulders, I am not a fan of the blue bubbles, his index finger looks like a claw and that pink that is over the Oblivion key is not attracting.

    3. B. This picture could have won if: There was no green in there to begin with, his left arm wasn't red, no boxes, and the end of the Kingdom Key wasn't all messed up. Great effects; you blew it up with the saturation and the boxes.
     
  15. Noctis

    Noctis Lucis Caelum

    C - Very, very pretty! Everything work well, and the flow is nice.
    B - Interesting, but I don't like the coloring used on Sora. :\
    A - It definitely could have used some sharpening. I kinda like the text, though.
     
  16. Plasmos

    Plasmos Plasmos

    Winning Votes.

    1. - Ric = 33 Points.

    2. - keybladelegacy = 23 Points.

    3. - Zol = 20 Points.​
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page