Debate on RP Ideas

So I have a few ideas for new RP's however I can't seem to make up my mind on which RP would be more succesful and appealing to the KHPlanet RP community.The different RP's are listed out...

1.) X-Men: The Next Generation= Sequel Canon RP to the X-Men film "X-Men: The Last Stand"
It's been quite a few years since Jean, Scott, and the Professor have passed away. Since then many mutants have been getting cures. Slowly over the years though a vacine for every human has been created to stop themselves from becoming mutants. The number of mutants have slowly been dropping ever since then. Current mutants have slowly been hunted down and have had to go into hiding.

It's been 15 years, Storm and Logan both still have the mansion and have been trying to make it a safe haven for mutants, but there is a threat about the mansion being discovered. When a group of 4 young mutants come to the mansion to learn to control their powers and escape government, Logan starts to discover clues of a remarkable discovery, Professor X is alive. The X-Men don't know if this is true or not, but they can only hope that he may be able to make everything alright.
Possible CharacterTypes-
X-Men you can make a past X-Men character who still resides with the mansion, you can make Storm, or Logan
4 young new X-Men
Villianous Mutants the one's causing riots against government
Government Officials trying to hunt down mutants

2.) Keyblade Academy- canon Kingdom Hearts RP.
Long, long ago children wouild be born with a special mark that showed signs that they would become keyblade wielders. People feared keyblade wielders until a school on an abandoned world of the Land of Departure vowed to teach children of keyblades to use their power for good to protect the worlds and fight for the light. Every child would eventually graduate and get assigned to a world to protect, so the school prooved itself to be helpful, however corruption of power can't always hide away.
Character Types=
Keyblade Appentices/Students
Keyblade Masters serving as teachers
A corrupted or maybe a group of corrupted keybladers of the shadows

3.) We're Not Dead- Orginal RP
When a group of teenagers find themselves fooling around in the grave yard, the find themselves soon in the underworld, the world designed for the dead, the problem is they're not dead. Can the teens fight through and get back before it's too late or will they join the dead?
Character Types-
Group of Teens
The Dead

4.) Chroniclesof Narnia: The Young Narnian- Canon RP, note- yeah I know another Narnia RP from me. Well in the past I never actually read the books(I read the Lion, Witch, Wardrobe, the Magicians Uncle, and part of Prince Caspian) but I have just finished reading the last book in the series(started reading the Horse and His Boy but I just didn't grasp it as well, I suppose
SPOILERS- Unless you have read the book, are up for doing research on the books. Please take note that below is a spoiler in itself.

Last Chance!!!!!!

It's been many years since the death of Susan's family. She has been living in New York City in America for quite sometime. She's happily married and eventually has a child. It would seem Susan's life is quite a happy one, her child would disagree. As the child lives life feeling locked up, she doesn't feel free like she think she does. When her mother take her and a few friends on a ski trip in Vermont, the daughter of Susan and her friends find themselves venturing through a cave of ice. To their amazement though they have been transported to a barren ice land, unknown to them that the world they stumbled upon is Narnia and it is up to them to bring back the once beautiful world and bring a new start.
Types of Characters-
Daughter of Susan
Susan's Friend


5.) The Quest- Original/Canon note
In a mythical land far away from this own land, there lives a kingdom so magnificent one can't help but bow down to its glory. It was once ruled by a very king king and queen until their son, a selfish boy sought an unknown revenge against the kingdom, he murdered his parents and took over the world enslaving many. A prophecy speaks though of twins born in the mythical land, twins that were safely taken to the our own land until the right time.

When the twins exploring out in the woods stumble accross a secret passage way to the mythical land, they are quickly captured and enslaved completely unknown to a powerful magic within them. This is the story on how two prodigals fight back a kingdom.
Types of Character-
Twins
Evil King
Rebels
Loyal Soldiers to the King


Thats about some of the ideas I have. As you can see they're kind of rough(except the first one, I had that idea for quite a while) but I want to know which one to devote my time to smooth it out and make into a RP.

 

Mary Sue, Godmodding, Powerplaying usually occur when a character is thrown into the head honcho position, there have been plenty of characters able to jump into the position fairly easily.

A keyblade academy would be a little more equal. Granted there always will be that one or two leadership position characters who mainly jump and make themselves that, but however it's much more equal.

X-Men is a little more complex for straight in new members which I believe what wayward is referring to.

 

So we got...

X-Men: II
Keyblade Academy: I

 

Out of RP's that have been completed it would seem the only ones that do get completed, I know of a few non kh rp's that got completed. Just you know coming from one of the mods during RP's Golden Age *Shrugs*.


Here's the way I view it(but once again this view I'm not looking at because I'm going to be the creator and creator's always try to think highly of their RP's)...

X-Men: If enough people sign up and stick with it, I can see it lasting fairly far into the plot before a possible death, maybe it'll get lucky and be completed.

Keyblade Academy: If there IS a story and legit Plot instead of just "There's this keyblade academy, you're all students, now go RP whatever the heck you'd like because it'll die after a couple pages". I do have a plot planned out, it's just a matter of people sticking to the plot and not getting too far off track and even as apprentices not one steps forwards all "guess what I signed up as a student just like everybody else but in all truths my character's this awesome prodigal that owns!" then I can see possibly joining the ranking of New Organization where it lasts long, contains good twists, but may not necessarily be successful in sequels.

We're Not Dead: Originals I find so many with such great stories and I can't wait to be completed but because Originals are based off of a plotline and story created in the creators head, people don't know what to expect, know which path to journy down, now I've seen some of the more advance writers complete some pretty awesome legit originals, but once again it comes down to the RP'ers and if they ever have a doubt or idea contact the creator before assumption.

Young Narnian- This falls with X-Men, the down fall I see of this is the story left from the last Narnia book will be hard to create a story and I created this RP(though I may just end up writing a story and posting it up on a different writing site) to be an ending for Susan because she does get left behind, she's almost left in the dark.

The Quest: This one is similar to We're Not Dead in the case it is original with some plot ideas modeled around some of other common stories I know of. This comes down to the RP'ers and how loyal they stay to it. The thing with this one, this is just a modeled idea of mine, it's not completely molded yet into a RP success story, it's still in the stages of a story summary.


Summoner, I really feel like unless you're going to RP your vote shouldn't really count. I made this thread to see what RP ideas people are interested in and to see who'd be up for RP'ing it. I'll include vote though, so current standings...

X-Men: 3
Keyblade Academy: 2
The Quest(Original RP): 1