A different look at Xemnas (Spoilers will be shown)

not a bad theory really. however, when Xehanort lost his memories after his fight, he developed himself a new personality. becoming a Nobody didn't give him back his memories, he still only remembered things from his new life. so calling Aqua's armor 'friend' might have been a small lingering memory of Terra but he was still Xehanort in mind and thought.

 

I guess you didn't play birth by sleep..

 

That bit confused me. Why did it show Terra and Ventus at the Land of Departure? Especially since it was shown during Aqua's talk with Ansem, the Land of Departure was Castle Oblivion and Ven is comatose.

 

Well that statment sorta proved you wrong..You didn't know what entirely happened. So before you make a theory like this know the entire situation, meaning play/beat or at least read up on the game as I have.
As for your theory all you said was some nonsense about Xehnorts heartless really being Terra's Heartless..Well no, its Terra's body, true, but Terra's body with No memories of anything, and terra's body was then renamed Xehanort. So if you want to get technical i guess you can call it "terra's heartless" but the reason its evil is because Terra's body had Xehanorts heart, and Xehanorts Mind. And the body wasn't named terra, it was named Xehanort by Ansem the Wise. Who found "young Xehanort" as he noted in his Secret Report. Then AtW took Young Xehanort as his apprentice, along side other apprentices. This is when AtW and his apprentices started studying about the heart. AtW then believed that his and his apprentices studies were a threat to his world (raident garden), so he stopped them, as well as ordered his apprentices to stop. But his foremost student, Xehanort, didn't want to stop, he continued with the studies on the heart, and some how got the other apprentices to continue alongside him. Soon all the apprentices, Including Xehanort were consumed by darkness, and sent their teacher AtW to darkness, where AtW then plotted his revenge on his apprentices as the mastermind, DiZ. Soon, with their darkness AtW's apprentices fell so deep into darkness, that they were all turned into heartless. blah blah blah blah i could go on for a while

but i will give you this, for not knowing the full situation, it was a rather good theory

 

My mistake it you said this:

though this still means it would be both Terra's heartless and nobody, if you believe its terra's nobody, you also have to believe its terra's heartless.

Yes, but its not Terra's its Xehenorts. how is it? because it may have been Terra's body, but as of the memory loss its Xehanorts body. Not terra's anymore.
Also i'll repeat this, Xehanort lost his heart, creating a Heartless <--, of that heartless came out Xehanorts Nobody, they both belon to Xehanort

Either you stopped in the middle, or you didn't fully grasp it. Like i said you didn't really know the whole situation, or you wouldn't made a theory like this, though its not a horrible theory. Its good and i appreciate it, because its a theory with thought in it

Yea, i know but, Ansem said "we will call him Xehanort",<-- not exact translation, even though thats all he could say, Ansem found him and named him that basically. thats the only reason i said that.

Xemnas has been confirmed to be xehanorts heartless. Why his name is splled out Ansem we don't know yet, its still a mystery

 

Isn't it for the same reason that Xehanort's heartless called himself Ansem? I think that he did it out of hatred for Ansem. What better way to deface your teacher's name than to parade around as him doing bad things?

 

Thats what i was thinking.

and yes this makes sense, but idk its not confirmed, because Xehanort would have to be going by Ansem before he lost his heart.